One of the detectives split from the scene in order to interview the girl's father; the other remained with Cinnabar, thinking that a fresh set of eyes might reveal something, perhaps a small detail they had overlooked.
* * * * *
"Mr. Quigly," said the detective, offering a hand to the grief-stricken father. "My name is Detective Hallam. I'm truly sorry for your loss, sir. I do have a few questions for you, but these can wait if you don't feel up to it."
Alwin Quigly was seated on a bench behind his home. He hadn't even looked up when the detective approached; but when the man spoke, when he offered to shake hands, Alwin gestured that the man should sit and then said and did nothing for a full minute. Then, quietly:
"My little girl."
Alwin's lined face, previously expressionless, now grew sad, as though he were remembering ... something. He closed his eyes; he buried his face in his hands and sighed, a long, heavy sigh, but Alwin Quigly did not weep again.
From behind his hands Alwin said: "Ask."
Having seated himself in the meantime, Hallam said: "Yes, sir. Please let me know if you want to stop at any time." Removing a small book and a wrapped stick of charcoal from his coat pocket -- the same book he had used at the Pangbourn farm -- Hallam prepared to write down his questions and Alwin's answers, as well as anything else he thought pertinent.
"Mr. Quigly, when was the last time you saw Laura alive?"
At first there was no answer from the other man. Hallam was about to say Alwin's name, to get his attention, when Alwin abruptly rose from the bench and walked a few paces away -- toward the cellar; toward that scene plucked from the bowels of Hell. Hallam thought to follow, but waited instead, gazing at the man's back with his book and charcoal ready.
But Alwin stopped, knowing what was down there. Knowing that looking again would not bring her back. So after a moment he returned to the bench, seating himself again; and then, still not looking at the detective, answered the question.
"Yesterday, just before she went to bed. An hour or so after I went to the Waiting Lady -- you know the place, I'm sure."
"I do," said Hallam. "I know of it, at least. Go on."
"I waited an hour because I wanted to be sure she was sound asleep. She knew I drank, but not how much. Well, tonight I got so drunk I couldn't even make it home. Friends of mine at the tavern dragged me out, dunked me in a tub as many times as it took to sober me up, and then told me to sleep it off there. So I did. Then this morning I came home and..."
Hallam was nodding and writing, but when Alwin paused he stopped to glance at the other man. Alwin was dry-washing his hands; his lips trembled.
"What sort of monster could do this? Is it the Baie? I've heard stories, Detective. Do you know something? Anything?" Alwin Quigly turned to face the detective, and there was a plea in his eyes: find who or what did this to my little girl, and then make
them suffer.
"Well, we've reasoned that it is not the Baie. We believe it is a man. An exceedingly cruel and violent man, but a man. Can you think of anyone who might want to hurt or kill her? Say, a boy or man she rejected. Someone who would hold a grudge or had a fierce temper."
"No," said Alwin, withdrawing once more into his shell of formless grief. In a whisper he said, "My little rose..."
Hallam looked sharply at the girl's father. "What did you just say?"
Alwin Quigly blinked, then looked back at the detective. "I said, 'my little rose'. That was her nickname."
* * * * *
The puncture wounds just below her chin entered through the bottom of her mouth and framed her tongue on both sides. Some of her teeth were scraped, chipped; the roof of her mouth had a slight puckering at two points, as if poked or irritated repeatedly by something sharp. The slash in her throat revealed little that could not be readily seen, and was obviously the cause of death -- no one could survive such a wound. The stumps where Laura's limbs used to be were cut cleanly; the shoulder and hip bones were intact. Perhaps the killer had pared away the skin and underlying muscle and tissues and then twisted or jerked the arm out of its socket?
"High Constable," called the detective with him in the cellar. "Have a look here."
When Cinnabar joined him, the detective indicated the wall where the tools were hanging from or supported by a variety of pegs and hooks. Apparently Mr. Quigly was a talented fellow: there was an assortment of quality gardening and woodcarving tools, a few unfinished examples of the latter resting on a nearby shelf -- a turtle, a dragon, a horse.
"Judging by the size of the pegs here and this hook here," said the detective, gesturing to each as it was named, "I'd say there used to be a hammer and a chisel on this wall. Not the only set Mr. Quigly owns, but it's plain to see these are missing -- everything else is here, untouched except for minor blood spatter. You'll find this interesting, too."
The detective led the High Constable further down the row of pegs and hooks -- to a set of pliers. Pliers with blackened tips, as if the metal had been exposed to fire.
"Our man left these for us," explained the detective. "A gift, I suppose.
"Oh," added the detective, "over here." They moved to a corner of the cellar where the blood had failed to pool and congeal. "We barely noticed it when we came in because it was in the shadows -- need a candle or a lamp down here even during the day, as you can see -- but when we started searching we found this."
"This," as it turned out, was a small pile of scorched wood and ashes. Here and there were fragments of burned leather, but not enough to piece together even the toe of a boot.
"We didn't know what was burned," said the detective, "not at first. But after searching the house it wasn't too difficult to figure out.
"Our man burned his clothes, High Constable. He used Mr. Quigly's tub to clean up, stole a set of the man's clothes, and then, of all things, scrubbed the floors in the house. It doesn't stop there, though. These bootprints?" The detective pointed to a set, just visible in the blood and packed dirt near the remains of the fire. "They belong to a pair of Mr. Quigly's boots. The rest are like them, too. So either Mr. Quigly is lying and murdered his own daughter, or our man was wearing his boots, too."
Another detective entered the cellar. This one had been inspecting the house for further clues. "Questioned the neighbors of six houses in each direction, High Constable. Nothing. He must have left before dawn, as that's when some of these people wake."
The first detective said: "We've noticed another pattern. It may be nothing, but it's worth noting. Dark hair, dark eyes -- the Pangbourn girl had them, too." He then shook his head. "No explanation for the cut hair, though. No trace of it."
Presently Detective Hallam joined them, a grim expression on his face.
"It's him," said Hallam, sounding disgusted. "We have a link. This girl's
nickname was Rose. That's how she escaped the net, High Constable."