"That's rather small of her." He pointed out, apparently non-plused. He certainly wasn't horrified, or if he was, it didn't show. There was likely no reason at this point to explain his reaction, but he would anyway. The raven deserved it after all, for previous explanations had been rather paltry and this new information certainly factored in. "From what I know of her, and maybe that knowledge will be furthered in this letter, she could have done something very similar even a month or two ago. By that point she had met me, had certain things freely given from me, be they objects or information or parts of my past. With enough time and effort, she could have crafted something, some facade, glamour, akin to myself. It would have been a worthwhile exercise, an act of art, something with real impact. She could have done if anyway, that's the point." Which was not in and of itself a reason to give away the keys to the castle, unless... "Now when she does it, it'll give her a moment's amusement but no lasting joy. It's too easy. She cavorts at one wedding. Will she do so at a second? Probably not. I took the fun out of for her and even bestowed upon her the specter of responsibility. It's in her care now when it was something she was violating before. And if you tell her this and then she does the opposite, then she's just acting like a little girl swaddled in spite. My reputation's worth less than her dignity."
Finn,
It's interesting that you did not think of it at length. It seemed straightforward. Here you are, changing lives, meting out justice or punishment, righting scales, and it all comes so naturally to you that you don't give it a second thought. That is not to say that the need was suspect, but the means? Likewise, why use the draught when you could have made them feel tired any number of other ways. I spent a year of my life thinking on my actions. Here you just slip into the easy, natural path without question. In what role were you cast here? Judge? Jury? Executioner? It sounds to me like you were little more than the blade. By what hand?
Shall we speak of truth or joy? Snakes? Is pleasure the highest end? Life has its limits so we must strive for enjoyment at all times? Pure, wanton hedonism? Who's to say that my joy is worth more than someone else's? Who's to say it isn't? What if I sacrifice joy for another but that other doesn't do the same for me? What if we both do it and ultimately neither of us feels any joy and our efforts are wasted? Am I to fear your joy? Then, am I to oppose it? Hardly. You're that rare sort of royal, the one who takes the weight of her crown seriously. You have more to fear from your own capacity for regret than I do for your desire for enjoyment.
Beasts and men. Empathy and awareness. Sentience. Glamour and iron. Names and souls. Freedom. Agelessness. There's such chaos in all of it. It all seems so capricious and haphazard. Yet there are rules and Laws, aren't there? Are they our attempts to force order? But why are you so thoroughly bound to your own then?
In the face of all that, you claim not to care about the past, nor the future, not really. Just the present. It's a strong boast and a paltry lie.
Your question is a good one, good enough that we need not talk about Catch (though I would) or of specifics of what I did. Would I do it again? No, I would not. I would do something better that achieves better results with less cost. As I said, I'd try not to do it alone. I do not think there's any way that what I did could have gone right, so your question is innately broken, good but broken. The path had consequences. Everything would have ended correctly? Perhaps, but with too many scars and too much emptiness along the way. Do you find that a satisfying answer despite it all? You should. I do.
You dislike themes. I imagine you dislike my organization. You position yourself against order itself? I wonder if that's not due to your longevity. Endless stagnation would be eternal punishment.
As for True Tom, and I am somewhat loathe to write these words, this goes back to questions we have discussed before. Are we who we are or are we what we are? How much does the one shape the other? What if you remove one element? What if you add another instead? My experiences have shaped me. Removing my capacity for introspection changed me in many ways, absolutely for the worse. That was freeing. Would removing my mortality do the same? Do we run this experiment upon ourselves every time we look for a piece of new information or seek out a new experience? In a year's time, will you become bored or afraid of stagnation or the pace of our words upon each other and wonder how interesting I might be if I was just a tiny bit different? Will that bring you enjoyment or regret?
I am arrogant enough to think I will never bore you. Is that the foolishness I shall finally be punished for?
Glenn